Australian context · reviewed November 2026
Consent, capacity and confidentiality in general practice
Rogers v Whitaker sets the Australian standard for disclosing material risks. In general practice the hard cases are minors, impaired capacity, interpreters and confidentiality.
What to know
- Rogers v Whitaker (1992)
- The High Court held that doctors must warn of material risks: risks a reasonable person in the patient’s position would want to know, or that this patient would want to know.
- Mature minors
- Gillick competence applies in Australian common law: a young person who understands the treatment and its consequences can consent. State rules differ; know where you will work. From 15, young people can have their own Medicare card.
- Capacity
- Presume capacity, assess it for the specific decision, and support the person to decide. If they lack it, look for an advance care directive or a substitute decision-maker under state law.
- Interpreters
- Use a professional interpreter through TIS National (free for GPs in private practice for Medicare services). Avoid family, especially children.
- Confidentiality limits
- Breach only where the law requires (notifiable diseases, child protection mandatory reporting) or where there is a serious threat to someone’s safety. Fitness to drive: advise the patient first, using Assessing fitness to drive.
How panels probe it
- “A 15-year-old asks for the contraceptive pill and does not want her parents told. What do you do?”
- “A patient with diabetes and recurrent hypos refuses to stop driving trucks. What now?”
- “How do you check capacity in a patient with early dementia refusing admission?”
Sample question
A 15-year-old asks you for the contraceptive pill and asks you not to tell her mother, who is also your patient. What do you do?
A framework for your answer
- Assess Gillick competence and document it.
- Explore safety: age of partner, coercion, abuse; mandatory reporting duties if concerned.
- Encourage, but do not require, involving a parent.
- If competent, prescribe, discuss STI testing and condoms, keep it confidential.
- Follow-up and safety-net; record the discussion.
Answer questions like this aloud, freeMarked against an Australian-practice rubric, with follow-ups.
Where candidates lose marks
- Refusing outright or telling the parent without her consent.
- Missing the child protection question.
- Using a family member to interpret a sensitive consultation.
Read the source
A study summary, not legal or regulatory advice. Laws, PBS listings, MBS items and Board standards change; check the source before relying on a detail.