All cheat sheets

Australian context · reviewed November 2026

Consent, capacity and confidentiality in general practice

Rogers v Whitaker sets the Australian standard for disclosing material risks. In general practice the hard cases are minors, impaired capacity, interpreters and confidentiality.

What to know

Rogers v Whitaker (1992)
The High Court held that doctors must warn of material risks: risks a reasonable person in the patient’s position would want to know, or that this patient would want to know.
Mature minors
Gillick competence applies in Australian common law: a young person who understands the treatment and its consequences can consent. State rules differ; know where you will work. From 15, young people can have their own Medicare card.
Capacity
Presume capacity, assess it for the specific decision, and support the person to decide. If they lack it, look for an advance care directive or a substitute decision-maker under state law.
Interpreters
Use a professional interpreter through TIS National (free for GPs in private practice for Medicare services). Avoid family, especially children.
Confidentiality limits
Breach only where the law requires (notifiable diseases, child protection mandatory reporting) or where there is a serious threat to someone’s safety. Fitness to drive: advise the patient first, using Assessing fitness to drive.

How panels probe it

  • “A 15-year-old asks for the contraceptive pill and does not want her parents told. What do you do?”
  • “A patient with diabetes and recurrent hypos refuses to stop driving trucks. What now?”
  • “How do you check capacity in a patient with early dementia refusing admission?”

Sample question

A 15-year-old asks you for the contraceptive pill and asks you not to tell her mother, who is also your patient. What do you do?

A framework for your answer

  1. Assess Gillick competence and document it.
  2. Explore safety: age of partner, coercion, abuse; mandatory reporting duties if concerned.
  3. Encourage, but do not require, involving a parent.
  4. If competent, prescribe, discuss STI testing and condoms, keep it confidential.
  5. Follow-up and safety-net; record the discussion.
Answer questions like this aloud, freeMarked against an Australian-practice rubric, with follow-ups.

Where candidates lose marks

  • Refusing outright or telling the parent without her consent.
  • Missing the child protection question.
  • Using a family member to interpret a sensitive consultation.

Read the source

A study summary, not legal or regulatory advice. Laws, PBS listings, MBS items and Board standards change; check the source before relying on a detail.

Further reading on Medbrella